當前位置

首頁 > 英語學習 > 英語學習方法 > 關於gre作文雷同分數的問題

關於gre作文雷同分數的問題

推薦人: 來源: 閱讀: 8.56K 次

在經歷了漫長的備考期之後,小夥伴終於迎來了考試,考完試之後,最在意的就是分數,那麼關於分數會出現一種狀況就是關於gre作文雷同分數的問題,一起來看看解析吧!

關於gre作文雷同分數的問題

關於gre作文雷同分數的問題

這個問題在江湖上已經糾結了很久,以至各種版本的傳聞和流言此起彼伏,搞得人心惶惶,我覺得有必要寫一篇文字澄清一下。一個基本的原則,就是一切以ETS網站的信息爲準,所有其他地方傳來的信息,包括本文的觀點,都是未經驗證的揣測,只能作爲參考。

ETS在GRE作文評分部分討論到獨立智力活動的問題:

Independent Intellectual Activity. Essay responses on the Analytical Writing section will be reviewed by ETS essay-similarity-detection software and by experienced essay readers during the scoring process. In light of the high value placed on independent intellectual activity within United States graduate schools and universities, ETS?? reserves the right to cancel test scores of any test taker when there is substantial evidence that an essay response includes, but is not limited to, any of the following:

由此可見,GRE的雷同處理將包括軟件的使用和閱卷員審覈兩部分。那麼軟件這一部分來講,我們有理由相信它主要是針對背誦範文的考生,運用計算機的範文數 據庫檢測答卷中是否有某一段文字爲抄襲。在計算機防止抄襲的工作中,做得比較好的是turnitin (//),我們可以通過這個網站了解全球最先進的計算機反抄襲技術也不過就是文字段落的配對。而對付閱卷員,則需要更 加仔細的避開以下ETS所列出的雷區:

Text that is similar to that found in one or more other GRE essay responses

這裏講的就是你的文字和其他考生的文字很接近。相信這項檢查將由計算機完成,其原理和turnitin相同。要避免這一點關鍵是不要背範文,以及要自己來寫。有同學會問如果句式一樣、內容不同行不行,我的看法是可以,因爲你的句子不會和數據庫中其他同學任何一個句子相似。

Quoting or paraphrasing, without attribution, language that appears in published or unpublished sources

這裏提到的是學術寫作中的一個經典問題,就是引述別人的文字時,需要指明這是原作者的工作,而不能將別人的工作據爲己有。這裏強調的是語言,因此只要每一 句話都是你自己造的就不會有這個問題。如果是引用別人的話,就註明出處即可。第二項也有可能通過計算機完成一部分,比如將一些名人名言錄入數據庫。

3) Unacknowledged use of work that has been produced through collaboration with others without citation of the contribution of others

這一項指的是在作文中使用了和別人合作的成果而未能引述他人的貢獻。比如說考生A和考生B在討論題庫的過程_同想出了某個思路,那麼兩個考生在考試中使 用這個思路時都必須引述另一個考生也參與了這個思考的事實。我想這條規則主要是針對考生在作文中重複使用相同的思路和例證。其實,ETS並沒有禁止使用別 人的東西,而只是強調用了別人的東西,一定要記得給別人相應的credit。

Essays that are submitted as work of the examinee when the words have, in fact, been borrowed from elsewhere or prepared by another person.

注意本項和第三項的關鍵詞有區別,第三項用的是work,是一個很寬泛的概念,涵蓋的內容包括文章的思路、例證等;而本項的關鍵詞是words,實際上就是text,這一點和第一項是一致的。第一項強調的是和其他考生的雷同而本項則是和其他已發表文章的雷同。

以上是筆者對ETS政策說明的解釋,屬於個人觀點,僅供參考。接下來,我們可以從獨立創作原則的正面角度來討論如何避免因雷同而被取消成績。要想避免雷同,考生應從以下幾個方面努力:

1) 在觀點上要具有洞察力,要有自己的原創特色。觀點是GRE作文考試的核心內容,考察考生能否對一個issue進行深入分析與思考並最終提出一個有層次的觀 點。有了原創觀點就不用擔心雷同。我這樣說也許有有點像讓快餓死的人去吃肉粥。如果真的要借鑑範文觀點,我建議應該儘可能做一些調整,以避免第二個雷區。 或者乾脆在文中講明這個思路是借鑑了哪一本參考書的。美國人對真小人比對僞君子要寬容。

2) 在語言上可以使用一些範文的句式,但是絕對不能照抄原文,而是要換掉一些關鍵詞。或者如果要借用關鍵詞,則必須使用別的句式。

3) 在結構上可以採取聲東擊西的策略,比如把北美範文用在120題的結構和破題策略用在210題上。

4) 在例證方面,使用範文用過的例證沒有問題,哪怕用那些被判雷同的例證也沒問題。例證是人類的共同知識,誰都可以使用,關鍵是我們不能用和範文作者同樣的思 路和語言來詮釋例證並展開類似的論證。因此,越是耳熟能詳的例證如牛頓與蘋果樹、愛迪生孵蛋,要寫出原創的內容就越困難,雷同的危險就越大。

總的來說,取消分數是一件很嚴重的事情,ETS決不會輕易的下手。這個政策背後的原則就是原創性,需要考生有自己的思想、自己的例證和自己的語言。我們一 方面可以在政策允許的範圍內對範文進行合法、合理的使用,另一方面更要積極培養我們自己的獨立思考能力,從根本上解決雷同問題。

GRE作文範文:Consciously Reconnecting

There may be times when we feel like our connection to the universe is closed. Maybe things don’t seem to be going well in our day, or our lives, or we may feel out of our element. The truth is, the universe is always there for us. We know that we create our experience with our thoughts, and this is another way we need to make a conscious decision about how we want to experience life. It is up to us to do the work of making the connection, because nobody can do it for us, though sometimes the universe may send us wake-up calls.

You can think of it as getting some fresh air. We are always breathing and the air is always around us, surrounding us, moving through us. But we may need to step outside of where we are in the moment—physically, mentally, or emotionally—and make the conscious choice to take a deep breath in order to feel the air coming in and going out. Whether this means stepping outside physically or merely shifting our thoughts, it is only our perception that changes; the air remains the same.

It is just as easy to reconnect with the universe. Using the same technique as a breath of fresh air, a deep breath can bring us back to our center. As we inhale, we fill our bodies with the oxygen needed to replenish our most basic physical needs, allowing the air to circulate within us. Exhaling, we release the stale, the used, the potentially toxic air, removing any blocks that may keep us from going deeper into the stillness that lies at our center where we connect to the universe. Feeling closed off does not need to be a negative experience. When we become conscious of it, we can think of the wholeness of a closed circuit, which allows electricity to connect and flow properly. Our bodies work the same way, and when we make that connection in our minds, it can help bring us back to the connection we seek.

GRE作文範文:Reclaiming Our Roots

Some cultures are more rooted to the earth and connected to their inherent spirituality. But every one of us, even those of us who have been disconnected from our roots for hundreds of years, comes from a place that was once inhabited by people who worshipped and honored the earth on which they lived. In other words, we can all claim this wisdom as an essential part of who we are.

One way we can begin to rediscover our roots is to explore the early earth-based religions practiced in the parts of the world that birthed our ancestors. If we explore the ancient spiritual practices of our ancestors, we will find that their practices and beliefs share many elements with Native American, African, and aboriginal religious traditions. People who are connected to the earth and honor her share a fundamental philosophy that we can claim as our own because we too are of the earth. Many of us have become so disconnected from the earth that it feels foreign and awkward to imagine communing with her or performing a ritual for her. If we are honest, though, we will find within ourselves a yearning to feel more connected, more grounded, and more at home in this world. This yearning can lead us back to our disowned roots, which, of course, leads us right into the heart of the earth.

As we begin to see more clearly the people we come from, we can begin to alter our perception of who we are now, laying claim to our inherent relatedness to the earth. We might celebrate this by observing the ancient calendar of solstices and equinoxes, celebrating and honoring the cycle of the seasons as our ancestors did, or we might explore any one of the many earth-based practices through reading or participating in ritual. When we do these things, we tap back into our roots, finding nourishment at the wellspring of our earthly origins, the source we share with all of humanity.